Keywords
Educational inequalities
Immigration and ethnicity
Canada
Submitted : 2024-03-09
Accepted : 2024-03-24
Published : 2024-04-08
Abstract
This paper presents the results of a research project on the intercultural climate in schools and the academic success of immigrant students in Quebec. The intercultural climate in eight secondary public schools is documented from the standpoint of various school and community stakeholders, students, and parents. More specifically, the paper focuses on the commitment to promoting cultural equity, which is identified through interviews with the targeted stakeholders on exclusionary practices and processes and the practices implemented to counter them. The results identify five areas of vulnerability among certain minoritized groups of students: the transition from welcoming to regular classes for those students learning French, evaluation and support for those experiencing learning or behavioral difficulties, the referral of these students to adult education programs or work-oriented training programs, their participation in extracurricular activities, and their access to special school projects. Nonetheless, some schools do report the introduction of many equity practices in response to the exclusionary ones. However, these initiatives are mostly occasional and voluntary and pertain to interactions between individuals. These findings call for a discussion on the importance of systemic and concerted initiatives towards achieving equity.
References
Christenson SL, Sheridan SM, 2001, Schools and Family. Creating Essential Connections for Learning, The Gilford Press, New York.
Inglis C, 2008, Planning for Cultural Diversity, UNESCO, Paris.
UNESCO, 2009, Guiding Principles for Inclusion in Education, UNESCO, Paris.
Potvin M, Larochelle-Audet J, Campbell ME, et al., 2015, Literature Review on Skills in Terms of Ethnocultural, Religious and Linguistic Diversity in the Training of School Personnel, According to Different Theoretical Currents, unpublished document, Observatory on Diversity and Equity Training, Montreal.
Potvin M, 2018, Guide for School Stakeholders: For Inclusive, Democratic and Anti-Discriminatory Educational Environments, unpublished document, Observatory on Diversity and Equity Training, Montreal.
Prud’homme L, Duchesne H, Bonvin P, et al., (eds.), 2016, Educational Inclusion: its Foundations, its Actors and its Practices, De Boeck Supérieur, Louvain-la-Neuve.
Ministry of Education and Higher Education (MEES), 2017, Educational Success Policy. The Pleasure of Learning, the Chance to Succeed, Government of Quebec, Quebec.
Higher Education Council (CSE), 2016, Resetting the Course for Equity. Report on the State and Needs of Education 2014–2016, Le Conseil, Sainte-Foy.
Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD), 2013, Equity and Quality in Education: How to Support Disadvantaged Students and Establishments, OECD Publishing, Paris.
Mc Andrew M, Balde A, Bakhshaei M, et al., 2015, The Educational Success of Students from Immigrant Backgrounds. Ten Years of Research and Intervention in Quebec, Presses de l’Université de Montréal, Montreal.
De Koninck Z, Armand F, 2012, Portrait of Reception and Educational Integration Services for Students from Immigrant Backgrounds, Directorate of Services to Cultural Communities of the Ministry of Education, Leisure and Sport, Quebec.
Potvin M, Leclercq JB, Vatz-Laaroussi M, et al., 2014, Young People Aged 16–24 from Immigration to Adult Education: Progress, Classification Process and Educational Orientation, unpublished document, FQRSC, Quebec.
Borri-Anadon C, 2014, Evaluative Practices of Speech Therapists with Regard to Students from Cultural Minorities: An Interpretative-Critical Research, Doctoral thesis, University of Quebec in Montreal (Canada).
Bakhshaei M, 2013, The Socio-Academic Experience of Montreal Students from South Asia: Family, Community and Systemic Dynamics, Doctoral thesis, University of Montreal (Canada).
Livingstone AM, Celemencki J, Calixte M, 2014, Youth Participatory Action Research and School Improvement. The Missing Voices of Black Youth in Montreal. Canadian Journal of Education, 37(1): 283–307.
Heine A, 2018, Representations of Teaching Staff on Educational Inequalities Experienced by Students from Immigrant Backgrounds: What Are the Challenges for Training? Education and Francophonie, 46(2): 168–188.
Mc Andrew M, 2008, Taking Cultural and Religious Diversity into Account in Schools: From Theory to Practice. Training Module for Managers, Government of Quebec, Quebec.
Thésée G, Carr P, 2007, Equity Measures and Cultural Discontinuities, in Solar C, Kanouté F, (eds.), Questions of Equity in Education and Training, Éditions Nouvelles, Montréal, 143–171.
Potvin M, 2013, Inclusive and Anti-Discriminatory Education: Foundations and Perspectives, in Mc Andrew M, Potvin M, Borri-Anadon C, (eds.), The Development of Inclusive Institutions in a Context of Diversity. Research, Training, Partnership, Presses de l’Université du Québec, Montreal, 9–26.
Ainscow M, Sandill A, 2010, Developing Inclusive Education Systems: The Role of Organisational Cultures and Leadership. International Journal of Inclusive Education, 14(4): 401–416.
Ekins A, 2017, Reconsidering Inclusion: Sustaining and Building Inclusive Practices in Schools, Routledge, New York.
Barbier JM, 2011, Theoretical Knowledge and Action Knowledge, Presses Universitaire de France, Paris.
Beillerot J, 2000, The Analysis of Professional Practices: Why This Expression, in Blanchard-Laville C, Fablet D, (eds.), Analyze Professional Practices, L’Harmattan, Paris, 21–28.
Artiles A, Dyson A, 2005, Inclusive Education in the Globalization Age: The Promise of Comparative Cultural-Historical Analysis, in Mitchell D, (eds.), Contextualizing Inclusive Education: Evaluating Old and New International Perspective, Routledge, New York, 37–63.
Benoit H, Plaisance E, 2009, Inclusive Education in France and Around the World: Presentation. The New Review of Adaptation and Schooling, 2009(5): 3–8.
Booth T, Ainscow M, 2002, Guide to Inclusive Education. Developing Learning and Participation in Schools, Center for the Study of Inclusive Education, Briston.
Thomazet S, 2008, Integration Has Limits, Inclusive School Does Not! Journal of Educational Sciences, 34(1): 123–139.
Zay D, 2012, Inclusive Education: A Response to Academic Failure? L’Harmattan, Paris.
Demeuse M, Baye A, 2008, Educational Equity Indicators. An Analysis of Academic and Social Segregation in European Countries. French Journal of Pedagogy, 2008(165): 91–103.
Damon J, 2011, Exclusion, Presses Universitaire de France, Paris.
Ramel S, Vienneau R, 2016, From the Sociological Foundations of Educational Inclusion to International Injunctions, in Prud'homme L, Duchesne H, Bonvin P, Vienneau R, (eds.), Educational Inclusion: Its Foundations, its Actors and its Practices, De Boeck Supérieur, Louvain-la-Neuve, 25–38.
Goyer R, Borri-Anadon C, 2019, The Inclusive Paradigm Through the Prism of Unequal Social Relations. McGill Journal of Education, 54(2): 194–205.
Tomasevski K, 2002, Annual Report Presented by Ms. Katarina Tomasevski, Special Rapporteur on the Right to Education, Pursuant to Resolution 2001/29 of the Commission on Human Rights, United Nations, Geneva, https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/457788
Ebersold S, Plaisance E, Zander C, 2016, Inclusive School for Students with Disabilities. Accessibility, Academic Success and Individual Career Paths, unpublished document, National School System Evaluation Council, Paris.
Higher Education Council (CSE), 2010, Combining Equity and Performance in Education, A Societal Challenge. Report on the State and Needs of Education 2008–2010, Le Conseil, Sainte-Foy.
Quebec Ministry of Education (MEQ), 2003, Education Statistical Bulletin. The Map of the School Population and the Deprivation Indices, Government of Quebec, Quebec.
Archambault I, Mc Andrew M, Audet G, et al., 2018, Towards a Multidimensional Theoretical Conception of Intercultural School Climate. Alterstice, 8(2): 103–134.
Paillé P, 1994, Analysis by Grounded Theory. Sociological Research Notebooks, 1994(23): 147–180.
Archambault I, Audet G, Borri-Anadon C, et al., 2019, The Impact of the Intercultural Climate of Establishments on the Educational Success of Students from Immigrant Backgrounds, Ministry of Education and Teaching, Quebec (Canada).
Rahm J, Malo A, Lepage M, 2016, Youth-Voice Driven After-School Science Clubs: A Tool to Develop New Alliances in Ethnically Diverse Communities in Support of Transformative Learning for Preservice Teachers and Youth. Alterstice, 6(1): 39–51.
Vidal M, 2019, On the Creation of School Exclusion in Disadvantaged and Multi-Ethnic Environments. McGill Journal of Education, 54(2): 206–225.
Ferrara M, Friant N, 2014, The Social Representations of Students in the First and Last Level of Secondary Education in French-Speaking Belgium in Relation to the Different Sectors. Educational and Professional Guidance, 43(4): 1–23.