Keywords
Family and education
Norms and regulations
Primary and elementary education
Switzerland
Submitted : 2024-01-30
Accepted : 2024-02-14
Published : 2024-02-29
Abstract
The recognition of the positive value of student diversity and their right to full participation are key aspects of inclusion as a means of managing heterogeneity of the school population from an equality perspective. As the school cannot welcome the diversity of children without including their families, the same logic needs to apply to the relationship between the school and parents, particularly in the current environment where the school-family partnership appears as a privileged institutional leverage in the fight against inequalities at school. Based on an ethnographical study exploring how the relationship between the school and the families builds up in a Swiss school located in a context of strong cultural diversity, this paper interrogates how the school norm can be the main limitation to the inclusion of students and parents who are unfamiliar with the school. Derived from field observations and interviews, our results show how the teachers tend to approach their relationship with new students and their parents from the standpoint of narrowly defined expected models, leading them to engage in a vain attempt to conform the students and parents when they deviate from these models. The possibility of entering the school system for students and parents unfamiliar with school is hindered by the exclusive and excluding normativity on which the models of the child and the parent expected by the teachers are grounded. Based on these observations, we discuss how an inclusive approach seems to us to require in the first place a necessary process of decentering from the school and teachers, as a condition for recognition of the actual child and parent.
References
Curchod-Ruedi D, Chessex-Viguet C, 2012, From the Family to the Initial Cycle of Schooling. Breakup or Transition? Curchod P, Doudin PA, Lafortune L, (eds), Transitions at School, Presses de l’Université du Québec, Quebec, 12–31.
Jacques M, Deslandes R, 2002, Kindergarten Transitions and School-Family Relationships, Lacharité C, Pronovost G, (eds), Understanding the Family – Proceedings of the 6th Quebec Research Symposium on the Family, Presses de l’Université du Québec, Trois-Rivières, 247–260.
Warzée A, Le Goff F, Mandon G, et al., 2006, The Place and Role of Parents in School (Report No. 2006-057), Ministry of National Education, Higher Education and Research, Paris.
Kherroubi M, 2008, Parents in the School, Érès, Ramonville-Saint-Agne.
Griebel W, Niesel R, 2003, Successful Transitions: Social Competencies Help Pave the Way into Kindergarten and School, Dunlop AW, Fabian H, (eds), European Early Childhood Education Research Journal: Transitions, Themed Monograph Series No. 1, 25–34.
Dockett S, Perry B, 2007, Transitions to School: Perceptions, Expectations, Experiences, UNSW Press, Sydney.
Dunlop AW, 2003, Bridging Children’s Early Education Transitions Through Parental Agency and Inclusion, Education in the North, 2003(1): 55–65.
Vincent C, Tomlinson S, 1997, Home-School Relationships: “The Swarming of Disciplinary Mechanisms?” British Educational Research Journal, 23(3): 361–377.
Patrikakou E, Weissberg R, Redding S, et al., 2005, School-Family Partnerships for Children’s Success, Teachers College Press, New York.
Duval J, Dumoulin C, Perron M, 2014, School-Family Collaboration and Prevention of Dropping Out of School: Avenues of Action for Elementary School Teachers. Canadian Journal of Education, 37(3): 1–23.
Thin D, 2009, Parental Work Under Tension: The Practices of Working-Class Families Put to the Test of School Logic. Social Information, 154(4): 70–76.
Changkakoti N, Akkari A, 2008, Families and Schools in a World of Diversity: Beyond Misunderstandings. Journal of Educational Sciences, 34(2): 419–441.
Monceau G, 2014, Unforeseen Effects of Measures Aimed at Bringing Distant Parents Closer to School. Education and Societies, 34(2): 71–85.
Périer P, 2005, Working-Class Schools and Families: Sociology of a Dispute, Presses Universitaire de Rennes, Rennes.
Ebersold S, 2005, Inclusion: From the Medical Model to the Managerial Model? Reliance, 16(2): 43–50.
Giuliani F, Payet JP, 2014, The School Logic of Proximity to Families. Introduction. Education and Societies, 34(2): 5–21.
Glasman D, 1992, School Outside of School. School Support and Neighborhoods, ESF Editor, Paris.
Brown C, Lan YC, 2015, A Qualitative Metasynthesis Comparing U.S. Teachers’ Conceptions of School Readiness Prior To and After the Implementation of NCLB. Teaching and Teacher Education, 2015(45): 1–13.
Prud’homme L, Vienneau R, Ramel S, et al., 2011, The Legitimacy of Diversity in Education: Reflection on Inclusion. Education and Francophonie, 39(2): 6–22.
McAndrew M, Potvin M, Borri-Anadon C, (éds), 2013, The Development of Inclusive Institutions in a Context of Diversity. Research, Training, Partnership, Presses de l’Université du Québec, Quebec.
Audet G, 2008, The Teacher-Parent Relationship of a Child from Another Culture from the Perspective of the Relationship with Otherness. Journal of Educational Sciences, 34(2): 333–350.
Pithon G, Asdih C, Larivée S, (éds), 2008, Building an “Educational Community.” A Family-School-Association Partnership, De Boeck University, Brussels.
Rousseau N, Thibodeau S, 2011, Appropriating an Inclusive Practice: A Look at the Feeling of Competence of Three School Teams at the Heart of a Change Process. Education and Francophonie, 39(2): 145–164.
Slee R, 2000, Professional Partnerships for Inclusive Education? Melbourne Studies in Education, 41(1): 1–15.
CDIP, 2011, The International Agreement of June 14, 2007 on the Harmonization of Compulsory Education (Concordat Harmos), Swiss Conference of Cantonal Directors of Public Education, Bern.
État DF, 2014, Law of September 9, 2014 on Compulsory Education (School Law, LS).
Larivée S, 2010, School-Family Collaboration in Quebec: What Are the Types of Involvement Favored by Parents of Preschool Children? Brougère G, (ed), Parents, Practices and Knowledge at Preschool, Peter Lang, Brussels, 181– 202.
Geertz C, 1973, Interpretation of Cultures, Basic Books, New York.
Payet JP, 2016, Observing the Disqualified School Worlds, Payet JP, (ed), Ethnography of School. Behind the Scenes of Educational and Socio-Educational Institutions, Presses Universitaire de Rennes, Rennes, 59–78.
Federal Statistical Office (FSO), 2017, ISCO 08 (International Standard Classification of Occupations), https://www.bfs.admin.ch/bfs/fr/home/statistiques/catalogues-banques-donnees/publications.assetdetail.4082546.html
Arborio AM, Fournier P, 2008, The Investigation and Its Methods. Direct Observation, Armand Colin, Paris.
Miles M, Huberman M, 2003, Analysis of Qualitative Data, De Boeck, Brussels.
Paillé P, Mucchielli A, 2012, Qualitative Analysis in Human and Social Sciences, Armand Colin, Paris.
Conus X, Ogay T, 2018, When the Teacher Imagines Collaborating with the Parent. Case Study Around Trust. International Journal of Family Education, 44(2): 45–65.
Conus X, 2017, Parents and Teachers in a Context of Cultural Diversity: What Negotiation of Roles? Inequalities and Role Tensions Around the ‘Normalization’ of Parental Practices, Doctoral thesis, University of Friborg (Switzerland).
Conus X, Ogay T, 2020, Communication Between Teachers and Minority Parents During the First Interview: Mirror Effect of Role Extension and Restriction, Pelletier L, Lenoir A, (eds), Critical Views on the School-Family(s) Relationship, Edition of Contemporary Archives, Paris, 51–68.
Baquedano-Lopez P, Alexander RA, Hernandez S, 2013, Equity Issues in Parental and Community Involvement in Schools: What Teacher Educators Need to Know. Review of Research in Education, 37(1): 149–182.
Payet JP, Giuliani F, 2014, The School-Socially Disqualified Family Relationship Faces the Challenge of Creating a Common World: Practices, Tests and Limits. Education and Societies, 34(2): 55–70.
Durler H, 2015, Compulsory Autonomy: Sociology of Self-Government at School, Presses Universitaire de Rennes, Rennes.
Kim Y, 2009, Minority Parental Involvement and School Barriers: Moving the Focus Away from Deficiencies of Parents. Educational Research Review, 4(2): 80–102.
Petriwskyj A, 2010, Diversity and Inclusion in the Early Years. International Journal of Inclusive Education, 14(2): 195–212.
Cargile AC, Bolkan S, 2013, Mitigating Inter- and Intra-Group Ethnocentrism: Comparing the Effects of Culture Knowledge, Exposure, and Uncertainty Intolerance. International Journal of Intercultural Relations, 37(3): 345–353.
Neyrand G, 2011, Supporting and Controlling Parents, Erès, Toulouse.
Bonnery S, (éd), 2015, Educational Supports and Educational Inequalities: Sociological Studies, La Dispute, Paris.
Rochex JY, Crinon J, 2011, The Construction of Educational Inequalities. At the Heart of Teaching Practices and Systems, Rennes University Press, Rennes.
Périer P, 2015, The Child Between Two Worlds: Parental Disqualification and Educational Empowerment. Educational Sciences - For the New Era, 2015(48): 105–126.
Périer P, 2012, Some Principles of Justice in the Relationship Between Parents and School. Education & Didactics, 6(1): 85–96.
Dubet F, 1997, School, Families: The Misunderstanding, Textual, Paris.