Research on the Optimization of Internal Governance Structure of Higher Vocational Colleges under the Mixed-Ownership School- Running Model
Download PDF

Keywords

Mixed-ownership school-running
Higher vocational education
Internal governance structure
Governance typology
Incomplete contract theory
Legitimacy mechanism

DOI

10.26689/erd.v8i2.14321

Submitted : 2026-03-01
Accepted : 2026-03-16
Published : 2026-03-31

Abstract

Mixed-ownership school-running is regarded as a pivotal institutional innovation for China to deepen the integration of industry and education and stimulate the vitality of school operation. However, its internal governance practice often falls into the predicament of “formal integration but substantive disconnection”. The crux lies in the lack of a scientific typology of governance models, leading to overly general policy recommendations. Adopting the normative theoretical research method, this paper integrates the incomplete contract theory and the legitimacy mechanism of neoinstitutionalism to construct a two-dimensional governance typology with the depth of property right integration and the ownership of dominant power as the core coordinates. The research finds that different types of mixed-ownership higher vocational colleges face distinctly different core governance contradictions and are constrained by multiple legitimacy demands. On this basis, differentiated optimization principles are proposed: for the resource cooperation - school-led type, the model of “power and responsibility list + collaboration platform” should be implemented; for the legal entity - enterprise-led type, a framework of “public welfare priority and dynamic checks and balances” must be established. This typology framework provides a theoretical tool for clarifying complex governance practices and points out the key path from formal integration to substantive co-governance.

References

Su ZG, 2020, Governance Community: An Innovative Exploration of the Governance Structure of Higher Vocational Education under the Background of Typological Education. Chinese Vocational and Technical Education, 2020(07): 61–65.

Peng YF, 2024, Research on the Problems and Countermeasures of Mixed-Ownership School-Running of Higher Vocational Colleges in Sichuan Province, thesis, Southwest University.

Yan WQ, 2011, Research on the Governance Structure of Chinese Universities. People’s Publishing House, Beijing.

Liu XJ, Sun R, 2023, Goal Orientation, Practical Dilemmas and Path Optimization of Mixed-Ownership Reform in Higher Vocational Colleges. Education and Vocation, 2023(16): 55–60.

Yang Y, 2021, Research on the Problems and Countermeasures of Mixed-Ownership Reform in Public Higher Vocational Colleges. Chinese Vocational and Technical Education, 2021(22): 72–75 + 96.

Li Y, 2024, Research on the Risks of Mixed-Ownership School-Running in Higher Vocational Colleges, thesis, Qufu Normal University.

Zheng Q G, Xu S J, 2023, Legitimacy and Agency: Dilemmas and Solutions of Mixed-Ownership School-Running in Higher Vocational Colleges. Vocational Education Forum, 39(09): 5–11.

Scott WR, 2010, Institutions and Organizations. China Renmin University Press, Beijing.

Wang F, 2021, Institutional Foundation and Breakthrough Path of Mixed-Ownership School-Running in Vocational Education. Chinese Vocational and Technical Education, 2021(12): 82–86.

Lao CM, 2016, Interests, Conflicts and Problems in Developing Mixed-Ownership Vocational Colleges. China Higher Education Research, 2016(08): 101–105.

Henkel M, Little B, 2005, The State, Higher Education and the Market. Educational Science Publishing House, Beijing.

Chen DQ, 2016, A Re-examination of the German Dual System of Vocational Education. China Higher Education Research, 2016(02): 92–96.

Giroux HA, 2003, Selling Out Higher Education. Policy Futures in Education, 1(1): 179–200.

Luo QX, 2021, Research on the Legitimacy of Mixed-Ownership School-Running in Colleges and Universities under the Background of Industry-Education Integration, thesis, Anhui University.

Zhang R, 2021, Research on the Financing Risk Governance of Modern Vocational Education, thesis, Tianjin University.