Towards Substantial Equivalence through Curricular Alignment in Sino-German Mechanical Engineering Education
Download PDF

Keywords

Sino-German cooperative education
Mechanical engineering
Curriculum alignment
Modular curriculum system
ECTS
TU9

DOI

10.26689/jcer.v9i12.13330

Submitted : 2025-12-11
Accepted : 2025-12-26
Published : 2026-01-10

Abstract

Against the backdrop of globalization, the mutual recognition of engineering qualifications and the cross-border mobility of talent have emerged as pivotal issues in higher education reform. As global leaders in manufacturing, China and Germany share a profound strategic synergy in engineering talent cultivation. However, graduates from Chinese undergraduate mechanical engineering programs frequently encounter significant hurdles regarding “curricular alignment” when applying for Master’s degrees at Germany’s elite research universities (specifically the TU9 Alliance). These challenges often result in high rejection rates or severe academic maladjustment post-admission. Adopting a comparative higher education perspective, this study critically analyses the Master’s admission mechanisms and undergraduate core curriculum systems of TU9 institutions, including RWTH Aachen, TUM, KIT, and the University of Stuttgart. Through a micro-level comparative analysis of syllabi, credit structures (ECTS conversion), and assessment paradigms in key modules—such as mathematics, engineering mechanics, and thermal-fluid sciences—this paper reveals structural discrepancies in “theoretical depth,” “scientific orientation,” and “process-oriented assessment” within Chinese engineering education. The findings indicate that the difficulty in achieving substantive equivalence stems fundamentally from the crowding out of professional hours by general education courses, the fragmentation of knowledge in core foundational modules, and a misalignment between Chinese credit calculations and European standards. Consequently, this paper proposes a reform scheme for mechanical engineering curricula aimed at international alignment. This includes modular curriculum reconstruction, learning-outcome-based syllabus design, and the establishment of a hybrid assessment system, providing theoretical support and practical pathways for Sino-German cooperative education and the internationalization of engineering education.

References

Auschner E, Jiang L, 2025, Implementing Chinese Student Support Services at a German Technical University. Journal of International Students, 15(5): 63–80.

Investigation Report on German Engineering Education Accreditation, Reform and Development, 2006, Research in Higher Education of Engineering, (1): 4.

Fu X, Gao Y, Jiang L, 2024, Exploration of the Talent Cultivation System in Sino-German Cooperative Education under the Background of International Engineering Education Accreditation. Western China Quality Education, 10(16): 91–94.

Keprate A, Woodford S, Borrajol R, 2023, From Theory to Practice: Leveraging Project-Based Learning to Cultivate Student Engagement in Mechanical Engineering Education, 2023 IEEE International Conference on Industrial Engineering and Engineering Management (IEEM).

Jie K, 2023, Discussion on Practice Teaching Model of Mechanical and Electronic Engineering Specialty in the View of New Subject. The Theory and Practice of Innovation and Entrepreneurship, 6(09): 133–135 + 43.

München TU, 2024, Examination and Study Regulations for the Bachelor’s Degree Program in Mechanical Engineering at the Technical University of Munich.

Module Handbook Bachelor’s Program Mechanical Engineering International (B.Sc.), 2025.

Ruiz-Torrubiano R, Knopp S, Krystallidis A, et al., 2024, A Scheduling Perspective on Modular Educational Systems in Europe. Heliyon, 10(21): e39694.

Jinye Z, 2020, Comparative Study on the Practice Teaching System of Engineering Colleges between China and Germany, dissertation, Harbin University of Science and Technology.

Dexin H, 2022, Construction Logic and Action Path of Engineering Education Accreditation System in Germany. Higher Education Development and Evaluation, 38(1).

Kun G, 2023, Research on the Implementation Path and Optimization Strategy of Industry-Education Integration in Application-Oriented Universities—Take the Mechanical Major of Shanxi D University as an Example.

Ye Y, 2022, Study on the Problems and Strategies of Talent Training of Mechanical Majors under the Background of Emerging Engineering, dissertation.

Yijing Z, 2021, A Comparative Study on the Reform of Undergraduate Engineering Education between China and the United States for Advanced Manufacturing, dissertation, Harbin University of Science and Technology.

Gan M, 2021, A Comparative Analysis of Practical Teaching for Undergraduate Mechanical Engineering Majors in China and the United States. Journal of Higher Education, 7(32): 38–41.

Qi Z, 2021, Research on the Optimization Strategy of the Talent Training Mode of Local Colleges and Universities under the Background of Engineering Accreditation-Based on the Analysis of the Mechanical Specialty of Shandong D College, dissertation.

Jianghua H, 2020, Major Reform and Practice Oriented by Engineering Education Accreditation, dissertation.

Wei C, Hongxi W, Yunbo S, et al., 2021, From “Differential Learning” to “Broadening International Perspectives”: A Comparative Study of Teaching Models for Cultivating Mechanical Engineering Talents in Chinese and Foreign Universities. Journal of Higher Education, (3): 21–24, 9.

Van Den Beemt A, Macleod M, Van Der Veen J, et al., 2020, Interdisciplinary Engineering Education: A Review of Vision, Teaching, and Support. Journal of Engineering Education, 109(3): 508–555.

Jinjin L, Peiqing Y, 2020, Exploration on the Integrated Project-based Research-oriented Comprehensive Practical Teaching Mode under the Background of Emerging Engineering Education. China University Teaching, (10): 58–61.

Hongtao X, Wei L, 2019, Research on the Improvement of Curriculum System and Course Content under the International Talent Cultivation Mode. Research in Higher Education of Engineering, (S1): 90–93.