Research Status and Challenges of Global Digital Governance Based on Knowledge Graph Analysis
Download PDF


Digital governance
Knowledge graph
Governance challenges



Submitted : 2023-04-29
Accepted : 2023-05-14
Published : 2023-05-29


Digital governance is an important issue in the digital age, involving the interests of governments, enterprises, individuals, and other parties. It is a key factor in achieving modernization of national governance and has attracted widespread attention from countries around the world. In this study, a Knowledge Graph was plotted to combine the research framework of digital governance through a big data system. The basic characteristics of digital governance research, the forefront of global digital governance research, and the current governance challenges facing global digital governance are also explained in this paper. The co-occurrence clustering analysis of keywords identified that the forefront of global digital governance research mainly includes digital government governance, artificial intelligence governance, digital platform governance, digital currency governance, etc. The main problems faced by digital governance at present include monopolistic challenges, the constant evolution of the “digital divide,” data privacy protection, and artificial intelligence ethics. Solutions proposed to these problems include the deep application of digital technologies such as artificial intelligence and blockchain, the protection and enhancement of digital rights, and international cooperation and sharing, to address the governance challenges in the digital age.


Huang J, Chen L, 2019, Research Progress and Future Prospects of Domestic Digital Governance. Theory and Reform, 2019(01): 86–95.

Zheng L, 2021, The Validity, Temperature, and Scale of Digital Governance. Governance Research, 37(2): 5–16 + 2.

Dunleavy P, Margetts H, Bastow S, et al., 2006, New Public Management is Dead—Long Live Digital-Era Governance. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 16(3): 467–494.

Han Z, Ma W, 2016, A Review of Theoretical Research on Digital Governance. Journal of Gansu Administration Institute, 2016(01): 23–35.

Chen T, Dong YZ, Ma L, et al., 2016, Promoting Government Services and Social Governance Capacity Through “Internet Plus Government Services”. E-Government, 2016(08): 2–22.

Zhao RY, Xu C, 2013, Information Service Research Hotspots and Frontiers: A Visualization Analysis. Information Science, 31(12): 9–14.

Chen Y, Chen CM, Liu ZY, et al., 2015, Methodological Functions of CiteSpace Knowledge Map. Studies of Science, 33(2): 242–253.

Huang HQ, Yu J, Liao X, et al., 2019, A Review of Knowledge Graph Research. Computer Systems & Applications, 28(6): 1–12.

Wang L, Yan Q, Chen Y, 2018, Fifteen Years of Digital Governance Research: From Conceptual System to Governance Practice—A Visual Analysis Based on CiteSpace. E-government, 2018(4): 67–77.

Erkut B, 2020, From Digital Government to Digital Governance: Are We There Yet?. Sustainability, 12(3): 860.

Jia K, Jiang YH, 2017, Three Fundamental Issues of AI Governance: Technological Logic, Risk Challenges, and Public Policy Choices. Chinese Public Administration, 2017(10): 40–45.

Gasser U, Almeida VA, 2017, A Layered Model for AI Governance. IEEE Internet Computing, 21(6): 58–62.

Stokel-Walker C, Van Noorden R, 2023, What ChatGPT and generative AI Mean for Science. Nature, 614(7947): 214–216.

Illia L, Colleoni E, Zyglidopoulos S, 2023, Ethical Implications of Text Generation in the Age of Artificial Intelligence. Business Ethics, the Environment & Responsibility, 32(1): 201–210.

Jiang X, Huang Y, 2022, Market Order, Market Regulation, and Platform Governance in the Digital Era. Social Sciences Digest, 2022(03): 81–84.

Lu P, Zhou L, Fan X, 2023, Platform Governance and Sociological Participation. The Journal of Chinese Sociology, 10(1): 3.

Hu S, Xie G, 2022, Review and Prospect of the Development of Central Bank Digital Currency. Investment Research, 2022(01): 150–159.

Li Y, Xia J, 2020, Potential Risks and Its Preventive Strategies of Double Round Monopoly of Super Platform under the Background of Digital Economy. Reform, 2020(08): 58–67.

Ma Y, 2022, Mechanisms, Challenges, and Policy Recommendations for Digital Economy to Empower High-Quality Economic Development. Qiushi Journal, 2022(06): 74–83.

Van Dijk JA, 2006, Digital Divide Research, Achievements, and Shortcomings. Poetics, 34(4–5): 221–235.

Shan Y, 2019, Bridging the “Digital Divide”: Social participation in technology governance in non-equilibrium societies. Study on Chinese Socialism, 1(5): 68–76.

Wang C, Cao J, 2021, Security Risks and Governance Under the Construction of Digital New Infrastructure. Jiangsu Social Sciences, 2021(5): 88–99.

Floridi L, 2018, Soft Ethics, the Governance of the Digital and the General Data Protection Regulation. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A: Mathematical, Physical, and Engineering Sciences, 376(2133): 20180081.

Xu DQ, 2021, From Regulation to Governance: The Global Pattern and Practical Consensus of Digital Currency Regulation. Legal Science (Journal of Northwest University of Political Science and Law), 2021(2): 93–106.

Carr M, 2015, Power Plays in Global Internet Governance. Millennium, 43(2): 640–659.

Liu X, Yao L, Liu H, 2016, The Implications of State Governance for Effective Global Governance, 2016(04): 175–185.

Liu X, 2021, Digital Globalization and Global Digital Community. Foreign Social Sciences, 2021(5): 39–51 + 157.