Should Ecocide Be Criminalized in the European Union? — A Normative Legal Analysis from an EU Environmental Criminal Law Perspective
Download PDF

Keywords

Ecocide
European Union
Environmental crime
Criminal law
Human rights
Environmental protection

DOI

10.26689/ssr.v8i1.13809

Submitted : 2026-01-14
Accepted : 2026-01-29
Published : 2026-02-13

Abstract

The concept of ecocide has re-emerged in contemporary legal and policy discourse as a response to large-scale and irreversible environmental destruction. Within the European Union (EU), increasing concern over climate change, biodiversity loss, and corporate accountability has intensified debates on whether ecocide should be recognized as a criminal offence under EU law. This article examines the legal, philosophical, and normative justifications for the criminalization of ecocide in the EU. Through a doctrinal and normative legal analysis, the article evaluates the adequacy of existing EU environmental and criminal law frameworks, explores the relationship between environmental protection and human rights, and assesses alternative regulatory approaches. The article argues that current legal mechanisms remain fragmented and insufficient to address severe environmental harm and that the criminalization of ecocide would fulfil both preventive and expressive functions within EU law. The article concludes that the adoption of a harmonized and comprehensive definition of ecocide is a necessary step towards strengthening environmental protection and legal accountability in the European Union.

References

Sands P, Peel J, Fabra A, et al., 2018, Principles of International Environmental Law (4th ed.). Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

Falk R, 1973, Environmental Warfare and Ecocide—Facts, Appraisal, and Proposals. Bulletin of Peace Proposals, 4(1): 80–96.

Galston AW, 1970, Environmental Warfare and Ecocide. Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists, 26(1): 26–31.

Gray M, 1996, The International Crime of Ecocide. California Western International Law Journal, 26(2): 215–271.

European Parliament Research Service (EPRS), 2020, Environmental Crime in the European Union. European Parliament, Brussels.

Faure M, Visser M, 2019, Environmental Criminal Law in the European Union: A Comparative Perspective. European Energy and Environmental Law Review, 28(3): 85–97.

Independent Expert Panel for the Legal Definition of Ecocide, 2021, Proposed Definition of Ecocide. Brussels.

Megret F, 2021, The Problem of an International Crime of Ecocide. International Criminal Law Review, 21(3): 563–596.

Duff RA, 2001, Punishment, Communication, and Community. Oxford University Press, Oxford.

Feinberg J, 1970, The Moral Limits of the Criminal Law, Volume I: Harm to Others. Oxford University Press, Oxford.

Higgins P, 2010, Eradicating Ecocide: Laws and Governance to Prevent the Destruction of Our Planet. Shepheard-Walwyn, London.

Boyle A, 2012, Human Rights and the Environment: Where Next? European Journal of International Law, 23(3): 613–642.

Knox JH, 2018, Human Rights, Environmental Protection, and the Sustainable Development Goals. United Nations, Geneva.