Effectiveness of Comprehensive Nursing Management in Enhancing Blood Donation Outcomes and Donor Experience: A Comparative Study
Download PDF

Keywords

Comprehensive nursing management
Blood donation service at blood stations
Adverse reactions
Comfort
Quality of care

DOI

10.26689/jcnr.v8i5.7356

Submitted : 2024-05-26
Accepted : 2024-06-10
Published : 2024-06-25

Abstract

Objective: To assess the management effect of comprehensive nursing management on blood donation services in blood stations. Methods: Sixty-four individuals who donated blood at a blood station between September 2021 and September 2023 were selected and randomly assigned into two groups of 32 each. The first group received comprehensive nursing management, while the second group received routine nursing management. Blood donation indexes and observational indexes such as adverse reactions were compared between the groups. Results: The total blood donation volume and qualified blood donation volume were higher in the first group than in the second group. The amount of discarded blood and the rate of blood discards were lower in the first group compared to the second group (P < 0.05). Additionally, the adverse reaction rate in the first group was lower, the blood donation comfort scores were higher, the psychological state scores were lower, and the quality of care scores were higher than those in the second group (P < 0.05). Conclusion: Comprehensive nursing management can improve the efficiency of blood donation, reduce the rate of blood discards, decrease the incidence of adverse reactions, alleviate negative psychological states of blood donors, and enhance both the comfort level of blood donation and the quality of care provided.

References

Huang D, Li S, Wang M, et al., 2020, Observation on the Effect of Quality Control Circle on Reducing the Incidence of Insufficient Volume of Whole Blood Collection. Chinese Journal of Blood Transfusion, 33(1): 76–78.

Li J, Liao X, Dang X, 2020, Analysis of the Application Effect of Humanized Nursing Model in the Care of Unpaid Blood Donors. Guizhou Medicine, 44(3): 490–491.

Zhang R, Chen Y, Guo D, et al., 2021, Analysis of Adverse Reactions to Blood Donation and Satisfaction of Blood Donors in Different Blood Collection Care Models. South China Preventive Medicine, 47(1): 90–92.

He Y, Yin Y, 2023, Analysis of the Application of Psychological Care Model in the Process of Blood Donation. Guizhou Medicine, 47(11): 1818–1819.

Wang F, Chen L, Yuan W, 2021, Application of Missionary Nursing in Blood Donors Under Graphic Communication Mode. Chinese Journal of Modern Nursing, 27(34): 4731–4734.

Cai C, Lu J, Zhu M, et al., 2022, Effect of Comprehensive Nursing Management Applied to Blood Donation Service in Blood Stations. China Health Industry, 19(11): 100–103.

Jiang S, Wang L, 2023, Application of Comprehensive Refined Nursing Management in Blood Donation Service of Blood Station. Tibetan Medicine, 44(1): 3–5.

Cha X, Bu J, 2021, Analysis of the Effect of Applying Comprehensive Nursing Management to Blood Donation Service in Blood Stations. Medical Food Therapy and Health, 19(27): 153–154.

Jia Y, 2020, The Effect of Applying Comprehensive Nursing Management Model and the Impact of Satisfaction in the Nursing Work of Blood Donation Without Compensation in Blood Stations. Heilongjiang Traditional Chinese Medicine, 49(6): 237–238.

Bian L, Bai Z, Xu H, et al., 2020, Analysis of the Effect of Comprehensive Nursing Management Applied to Blood Donation Service at Blood Stations. Journal of Contemporary Clinical Medicine, 33(6): 569–570.