Keywords
Ribavirin
Mumps
Meta-analysis
Submitted : 2022-11-13
Accepted : 2022-11-28
Published : 2022-12-13
Abstract
Objective: To compare the efficacy of cimetidine and ribavirin in the treatment of mumps by meta-analysis. Methods: Controlled trials of cimetidine and ribavirin in the treatment of mumps were searched through China National Knowledge Infrastructure (CNKI), Wanfang data, Cqvip, Pubmed, The Cochrane Library and EMBase databases up to September 2022. The effective rate, the time of swelling regression in parotid gland area and the rate of adverse reactions were analyzed by Review Manager 5.3 software. Results: The final 10 articles included 920 children, including 427 in the trial group and 447 in the control group. Meta analysis showed that the effective rate of cimetidine in the treatment of mumps was higher than that of ribavirin in routine treatment, with a statistically significant difference (odds ratio [OR] = 5.2, P < 0.00001); The time of swelling regression was statistically significant (OR = -1.28, P < 0.00001); The difference of adverse reaction rate was not statistically significant (OR = 0.73, P = 0.62). Conclusions: Compared with ribavirin, cimetidine is more effective in the treatment of mumps, with shorter swelling regression time without increases of adverse reactions.
References
Gu W, Xu E, Liu Y, et al., 2018, Analysis of Epidemiological Characteristics of Mumps in Hangzhou from 2005 to 2016. China Vaccine and Immunization, 24(1): 6.
Feng X, Xu S, Chen Y, 2021, Analysis of Epidemiological Characteristics of Mumps in Anshan City from 2015 to 2019. Practical Preventive Medicine, 2021(3): 372–374.
Cao Y, 2022, The Effect of Cimetidine Combined with Yunnan Baiyao Nasal Feeding on Neonatal Gastrointestinal Bleeding. China Modern Doctor, 60(2): 16–19.
Zhang B, Liu J, Luo D, 2008, The Immunomodulatory Effect of Cimetidine. China Pharmacy, 1: 3.
Liu Y, He Y, Shen X, 2017, Research Progress of Clinical Application of Cimetidine. China Pharmacy, 28(23): 3294–3298.
Wang Z, 2002, Evidence-Based Medicine and Meta-Analysis. Evidence-Based Medicine, 2: 50–52.
Bian Z, 2017, Clinical Study of Cimetidine in the Treatment of Children with Mumps. Psychiatrist, 23(26): 105.
Chen L, 2016, Clinical Effect of Cimetidine in the Treatment of Children with Mumps. Chinese Medicine Guide, 14 (15): 146–147.
Chen L, 1995, Clinical Analysis of Cimetidine in the Treatment of 40 Cases of Mumps. Gongqi Medical Journal, 8(4): 83–84.
Chen Q, 2012, Clinical Efficacy and Safety of Cimetidine in the Treatment of Children with Mumps. Contemporary Medicine, 18(22): 131.
Huang G, 2008, Cimetidine in the Treatment of 50 Children with Mumps. Journal of Practical Medicine, 24(11): 1988–1989.
Le J, Cheng Z, 2000, Analysis of the Efficacy of Cimetidine in the Treatment of Mumps. Anhui Medicine, 21(1): 36.
Liu X, 2016, Clinical Effect of Cimetidine in the Treatment of Children with Mumps. Digest of the Latest Medical Information in the World, 16(24): 96
Mao S, Yang Z, 2003, Observation on the Efficacy of Cimetidine in Adjuvant Treatment of 34 Cases of Mumps. Journal of Practical Cardiovascular and Cerebrovascular Diseases, 11(4): 249.
Shi J, 2017, Clinical Observation of Cimetidine in the Treatment of Children with Mumps. Chinese health care nutrition, 27(18): 286.
Sun L, 2015, Comparative Analysis of Ribavirin and Cimetidine in the Treatment of Children with Mumps. Chinese Health Standard Management, 6(11): 94–95.
Li X, 2022, Epidemiological Characteristics of Mumps in Baiyun District, Guangzhou from 2005 to 2020. Applied Preventive Medicine, 3: 286–288.
Wang W, An X, Zhu L, et al., 2022, Serological Analysis of Measles, Rubella and Mumps Antibodies in Healthy People of Different Age Groups in Liaoning Province in 2020. Disease Surveillance , 37(10): 1290–1293
Pang H, Shi W, Liu X, et al., 2021, Effects of MMR Vaccine Booster Immunization on Mumps Antibody Levels in Changning District, Shanghai. Shanghai Preventive Medicine, 2021(12): 1131–1135.
Zhang T, Li J, Zou W, et al., 2021, Gene Characteristics of Mumps Virus in Epidemic Mumps Cases in Hubei Province from 2015 to 2019. China Vaccines and Immunization, 26(05): 519–522.
Wang Y, Zhu Z, Deng L, et al., 2021, Epidemiological Characteristics and Viral Gene Characteristics of Mumps in China from 2018 to 2019. Acta Virology, 37(2): 356–362.
Zhang H, Yang X, Wu R, et al., 2021, Mumps Serology and Virus Genotype Surveillance in Fujian Province in 2018. Chinese Journal of Experimental and Clinical Virology, 35(5): 524–529.
Huang L, Xu Y, Li F, et al., 2022, Meta-Analysis of the Efficacy and Safety of Compound Glycyrrhizin Combined with Cimetidine in the Treatment of Children with Allergic Purpura. Anhui Medicine, 26: 8.
He Y, Shen X, Jiang D, 2018, Research Progress on the Mechanism of Radiation Protection of Cimetidine. China Pharmacy, 29(5): 707–710.