Keywords
Acne
Randomized controlled trial (RCT)
Meta analysis
Submitted : 2021-07-05
Accepted : 2021-07-20
Published : 2021-08-04
Abstract
Objective: To systematically evaluate the efficacy and safety of Loquat Qingfei Yin (LQFY) in the treatment of acne. Methods: Using computer retrieval, comprehensive collection of the full text database of Chinese journals till December 2020 (CNKI), Wanfang Data Knowledge Service Platform (Wanfang), Viper Database (VIP), PubMed, Cochrane Library, Medline were included in the LQFY addition or subtraction treatment of acne randomized controlled trial (RCT). Screening of the literatures included in the Note Express 3.2.0. Assessment of the risk of bias in trials using Cochrane collaboration tools, and used Rev Man 5.3 to evaluate the curative effect. Results: 25 RCT, all in Chinese, there were 2257 cases. Of the 1216 cases who were treated, control group was 1041 cases. A random effect model was used for Meta analysis. The results showed that the effective rate of the treatment group was significantly higher than that of the control group, Differences were statistically significant (P=0.94, I2=0%), RR=2.87, CI [2.25,95 per cent 3.67], P<0.00001. Conclusion: There are limited evidence that LQFY is safe and effective in treating acne. However, this conclusion needs to be confirmed by a more large-scale, multi-center, high-quality RCTs.
References
Zhao B., 2009, Chinese Clinical Dermatology, Jiangsu Phoenix Science and Technology Press, Nanjing, 1165.
Wang K, Xu M, Hu W, 2019, Observation of the Clinical Effect of Loquat Qingfei Yin in the Treatment of Acne. Chinese Medical Cosmetology. 9(11): 98-101.
Zhang R, Li F, Zhang M, 2019, Evaluation of the Effect and Adverse Reaction Rate of Loquat Qingfei Yin in the Treatment of Pulmonary and Stomach Damp-Heat Facial Acne, China Medical Cosmetology. 9(6): 104-107.
Zheng D, Zhang H, 2019, The Clinical Efficacy of Loquat Qingfei Yin in the Treatment of Acne Vulgaris of Lung Meridian Wind-Heat Type, Clinical Medical Journal. 47(6): 606-607.
Niu C, 2016, Observation on the Efficacy of the Method of Clearing The Lungs, Purging Heat, Removing Dampness and Removing Phlegm in the Treatment of Severe Acne, Primary Medical Forum. 20(23): 3267-3269
Hu Y, 2016, Observation on the Clinical Effect of Modified Loquat Qingfei Yin in the Treatment of 60 Cases of Acne, Health Today. 15(7): 19, 22.
Li Z, Ye W, 2016, Observation on the Efficacy of Loquat Qingfei Yin in the Treatment of Acne Vulgaris And Its Influence On Sex Hormone Levels, Chinese Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine. 31(2): 731-733.
Wang X, Zheng N, An Y, 2014, Clinical Observation on the Treatment of Acne Vulgaris Caused By Lung And Stomach Heat With Modified Loquat Qingfei Yin, Liaoning Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine. 41(9): 1799-1801.
Xu G, Kong R, 2013, Observation on the Efficacy of Loquat Qingfei Yin in the Treatment of Acne, Journal of Practical Traditional Chinese Medicine. 29(7): 529-530.
Wang S, Wu B, Zhu J, 2013, Effect of Loquat Qingfei Yin on Serum Androgen Levels in Female Patients with Acne Vulgaris. Journal of Shandong University of Traditional Chinese Medicine. 37(3): 230-231.
Ma Tianlong, 2013, Modified Loquat Qingfei Yin is Effective in Treating 84 Cases of Acne, Inner Mongolia Traditional Chinese Medicine. 32(23): 12-13.
Huang S, Chen L, 2013, Chen Li’s Clinical Observation on Treating Acne with Loquat Qingfei Yin, Journal of Liaoning University of Traditional Chinese Medicine. 15(10): 179-181.
Chen L, Zhou J, 2011, Observation on the Curative Effect of 53 Cases Of Acne Vulgaris Treated With Modified Loquat Qingfei Yin, Asia-Pacific Traditional Medicine. 07(4): 48-49.
Zhang Y, Huang Y, 2011, Treatment of 135 Cases Of Acne Vulgaris with Loquat Qingfei Yin, Modern Medicine and Health. 27(3): 334-335.
Chen Z, 2010, Clinical Observation on 65 Cases of Acne Treated with Loquat Qingfei Yin. Chinese Medicine Herald. 16(5): 62-63.
Jiang Z, 2010, Discussion on the Incidence of Acne and Clinical Observation of Loquat Qingfei Yin in the Treatment Of Acne Vulgaris, Nanjing University of Traditional Chinese Medicine. 45.
Xi Y, 2009, Modified Loquat Qingfei Yin in the Treatment of 40 Cases of Pulmonary Acne, Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine. 22(2): pp. 37-38.
Qi H, 2009, Clinical Study of Loquat Qingfei Granules in Treating Acne of Lung Meridian Wind-Heat Type, Heilongjiang Academy of Traditional Chinese Medicine, 50.
Liang X, Wang W, 2009, 32 Cases of Acne Vulgaris Treated with Pipi Qingfei Decoction, New Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine. 41(11): 87-87.
Shi X, Zhou R, Zhao Y, 2008, Loquat Qingfei Yin in the Treatment andPprevention of Acne Vulgaris Recurrence, Chinese Journal of Dermatology and Venereology. 22(6): 375-376.
Zhang L, 2006, Observation on the Therapeutic Effect of Loquat Qingfei Yin in the Treatment Of Lung-Gastric Damp-Heat Acne, Practical Clinical Medicine of Integrated Traditional Chinese and Western Medicine. 6(3): 31-32.
Wang Z, 2006, Observation on the Curative Effect of 28 Cases Of Acne Treated with Loquat Qingfei Yin, Yunnan Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine and Materia Medica. 27(6): 25-26.
Fu P, Ma S, 2005, Observation on the Curative Effect of Loquat Qingfei Yin in the Treatment Of Acne, Liaoning Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine. 32(7): 679-680.
Shen J, Wu M, 2003, Modified Loquat Qingfei Yin in the Treatment of 60 Cases of Acne Vulgaris, Heihe Science and Technology. (4): 160.
Li D, Cui H, 2003, Loquat Qingfei Yin for the Treatment of Moderate to Severe Acne Vulgaris, Heilongjiang Traditional Chinese Medicine (6): 30.
Ji H, Shan J, 2002, Loquat Qingfei Yin in the Treatment of Acne Vulgaris, Zhejiang Journal of Integrated Traditional Chinese and Western Medicine. 12(9): 566-567. [27] Ju Q, Fan WX, Gu J, et al., 2019, Chinese Acne Treatment Guidelines (2019 Revised Edition), Journal of Clinical Dermatology. (9): 583-588.
Cai H, Huang G, Zhao Y, et al., 2012, Mechanism of Modified Loquat Qingfei Yin in the Treatment of Malassezia Folliculitis, Contemporary Medicine. 18(22): 129-130.
Zhao Y, Jiang J, Tu H, et al., 2009, Modified Loquat Qingfei Yin in the Treatment of Malassezia Folliculitis Clinical Efficacy and Mechanism of Action, Chinese Journal of Integrated Traditional Chinese and Western Medicine Dermatology and Venereology. 8(01):11-13.
Xu H, Chen J, Liu J, et al., 2009, Effect of Jiawei Loquat Qingfei Granules on Anti-Keratosis and Testosterone Level in Rabbit Ear Acne Model, Chinese Journal of Dermatovenereology. 23(01): 13-15+28.