Keywords
Evaluating food safety policies
Positive list system
Simultaneous Buy and Sell system
Traceability
Submitted : 2021-07-28
Accepted : 2021-08-12
Published : 2021-08-27
Abstract
This study evaluated the impacts of food safety policies on Japan’s Simultaneous Buy and Sell rice imports through measuring tariff equivalents of food safety policies. In order to construct an estimated model, a Japanese consumer’s utility function is introduced and developed with consumer’s preference parameters and elasticity of substitution. In the empirical study part, Japan’s positive list system and rice traceability were analyzed and assessed as critical food safety policies. Results showed that after the implementation of the positive list system, consumers’ preference for foreign rice and the substitution elasticity diminished. This decreasing tendency was quite similar to the results after the enforcement of rice traceability. The tariff equivalents of food safety policies on imported rice fluctuated around ¥50 yen/kg from fiscal year 2000 to 2005 and decreased because of the global grain price hike after 2006. The tariff equivalents soared in 2010, which was induced by the traceability regulation, and then dulled during Japan’s earthquake and tsunami in 2011. Subsequently, after the recovery from natural disasters, the tariff equivalents of food safety policies became higher. Therefore, food safety policies had made imported rice less attractive, weakened the competitive power of rice exporting countries, and had statistically significant impacts on Japan’s rice importation.
References
Takahashi D, 2009, Quantitative Evaluation of the Japanese Rice Policy Reforms under the WTO Agreement on Agriculture. Economics Bulletin, 29: 712-25.
Bektasoglu B, Engelbert T, Brockmeier M, 2017, The Effect of Aggregation Bias: An NTB-modelling Analysis of Turkey’s Agro-food Trade with the EU. The World Economy, 40(10): 2255-76.
De Frahan BH, Vancauteren M, 2006, Harmonisation of Food Regulations and Trade in the Single Market: Evidence from Disaggregated Data. European Review of Agricultural Economics, 33(3): 337-60.
Disdier AC, Marette S, 2010, The Combination of Gravity and Welfare Approaches for Evaluating Nontariff Measures. American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 3(92): 713-26.
Fricke S, Chapman G, 2017, The Role of Standards in North-South Trade: The Case of Agricultural Exports from Sub-Saharan African Countries to the EU. Friedrich-Schiller-University Jena.
Genç M, Law D, 2014, A Gravity Model of Barriers to Trade in New Zealand. Treasury Working Paper Series, 14(05).
Gu GD, Niu XJ, Zhang Q, 2007, Empirical Study on the Impacts of Technical Barrier to Trade on International Trade – Taking Tea Trade Between China and Japan as an Example. Journal of International Trade, 6: 015.
Otsuki T, Wilson JS, Sewadeh M, 2001, What Price Precaution? European Harmonisation of Aflatoxin Regulations and African Groundnut Exports. European Review of Agricultural Economics, 28(3): 263-84.
Wood J, Wu J, Li Y, et al., 2017, The Economic Impact of SPS Measures on Agricultural Exports to China: An Empirical Analysis using the PPML Method. Social Sciences, 6(2), 51. doi: 10.3390/socsci6020051.
Calvin L, Krissoff B, 1998, Technical Barriers to Trade: A Case Study of Phytosanitary Barriers and U.S.-Japanese Apple Trade. Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics, 23(2): 351-66.
Gao QH, Ito S, Ogundari K, et al., 2016, Evaluating Welfare Effects of Rice Import Quota in Japan: Based on Measuring Non-Tariff Barriers of SBS Rice Imports. Sustainability, 8(8): 817-29.
Liu L, Yue CY, 2009, Non-Tariff Barriers to Trade Caused by SPS Measures and Customs Procedures with Product Quality Changes. Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics, 34(1): 196-212.
Nimenya N, Ndimira PF, de Frahan BH, 2012, Tariff Equivalents of Nontariff Measures: The Case of European Horticultural and Fish Imports from African Countries. Agricultural Economics, 6(43): 635-53.
Beghin JC, Bureau JC, 2001, Quantitative Policy Analysis of Sanitary, Phytosanitary and Technical Barriers to Trade. Économie Internationale, 3: 107-30.
Bao XH, 2005, Economic Assessment of SPS Measures Under the WTO Framework: An Analysis Based on Cost-Benefit. Finance and Trade Research, 5: 1-5.
Jiang JY, Wang DW, 2009, Evaluation and Analysis of Non-Tariff Barrier that China is Faced with. Journal of Northeastern University (Natural Science), 30(6): 782-85.
Bao XH, 2005, Economic Assessment of SPS Measures Under the WTO Framework: An Analysis Based on Cost-Benefit. Finance and Trade Research, 5: 1-5.
Bigsby H, 2009, Measuring the Consistency of Phytosanitary Measures. Soil Science Society of America Journal, 69(4): 1066-8.
Unnevehr LJ, Jensen HH, 1999, The Economic Implications of Using HACCP as a Food Safety Regulatory Standard. Food Policy, 24(6): 625-35.
Chen YH, Nie PY, 2016, Duopoly Competition in Food Industry Considering Corporate Social Responsibility. Quality Assurance and Safety of Crops and Foods, 8(1): 33-40.
Gawande K, 1997, A Test of a Theory of Strategically Retaliatory Trade Barriers. Southern Economic Journal, 64(2): 425
Gawande K, 1999, Trade Barriers as Outcomes from Two-Stage Games: Evidence. Canadian Journal of Economics, 32(4): 1028-56.
Yang B, 2007, The Cause of Technical Barriers to Trade: Game and Empirical Study. World Economy Study, 10: 41-7.
Chang CC, Lee HL, Hsu SH, 2013, Food Security-Global Trends and Region Perspective with Reference to East Asia. The Pacific Review (East Asia and Food (in) Security), 26(5): 589-613.
Engelbert T, Bektasoglu B, Brockmeier M, 2014, Moving Toward the EU or the Middle East? An Assessment of Alternative Turkish Foreign Policies Utilizing the GTAP Framework. Food Policy, 47(47): 46-61.
Fujiki H, 2000, Japanese Rice Market Liberalization: A Competitive Equilibrium Approach. Japanese Economic Review, 51(4): 492-518.
Wu GS, 2012, A Quantification Research of Non-Tariff Barriers on China’s Agricultural Product Import. Economic Survey, 1(5): 43-7.
Chen LJ, 2011, The Effect of China’s RMB Exchange Rate Movement on Its Agricultural Export: A Case Study of Export to Japan. China Agricultural Economic Review, 3(1): 26-41.
Zhai YL, Pang H, 2011, Notice of Retraction Impact of Positive List System on Vegetable Trade between China and Japan. International Conference on E-Business and E-Government (ICEE), : 1-4.
Dixit AK, Stiglitz JE, 1975, Monopolistic Competition and Optimum Product Diversity. American Economic Review, 67 (3): 297-308.
Shan LJ, 2008, The Study of Vegetables Export of China Based on the System of Green Barrier to Trade. PhD dissertation, Jiangnan University, Wuxi City, China.
Hicks J, 1932, The Theory of Wages, Macmillan London Press.
Robinson J, 1933, The Economics of Imperfect Competition, Macmillan Press.
Hayashi F, 2000, Econometrics, Princeton University Press.
Fell J, MacLaren D, 2013, The Welfare Cost of Japanese Rice Policy with Home-Good Preference and an Endogenous Import Price. Australian Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics, 57(4): 601-19.
Cai JS, 2004, Analyses on Structures of Minimum Access Rice Imports in Japan. PhD dissertation, Faculty of Agriculture in Tottori University, Japan.